- Published on
Brazil's Double Reversal: A Fourth Term, and the Market It Just Closed
- Authors
Two things in Brazil fell on 25 October.
Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva was re-elected to a record fourth term, having lost the first round three weeks earlier. And it was the final deadline for every licensed betting operator in the country to close its Brazilian business, following a ban enacted on 25 September - less than two years after Brazil had opened one of the largest regulated betting markets anywhere.
The coincidence of dates is just a coincidence. The pairing is not, and the second story is the more unusual of the two.
Table of contents
- The election: an unprecedented reversal
- Why Moscow commented
- The other reversal: a market opened, then closed
- The payments detail that matters
- Romania takes the gradual route
- What connects them
- What I would watch
The election: an unprecedented reversal
In the first round in early October, Lula finished second - 45.16% to Flavio Bolsonaro's 47.03%. Flavio, son of Jair and a close ally of the current US administration, went into the runoff as the leader.
In the runoff on 25 October, Lula took more than 51% with over 96% of votes counted, becoming the first candidate in Brazilian presidential history to overturn a first-round defeat. Flavio Bolsonaro has rejected the result and says he will mount a legal challenge.
That last part is worth sitting with for a moment, because it is the second time in a month this blog has had cause to note a losing candidate contesting a count. The US midterms produced two Senate races too close to call and a result the losing side accepted; Brazil has produced a clear margin and a result the losing side does not. Whether contesting a 51% runoff is a legal strategy or a political one, the pattern of treating a certified count as the opening of a negotiation rather than the end of one is now a recurring feature of elections in large democracies, and it is a slow-acting institutional risk rather than a dramatic one.
Why Moscow commented
The Kremlin welcomed Lula's re-election, with its spokesman specifically praising his contribution to bilateral ties and to the development of BRICS.
That is not a throwaway diplomatic courtesy, and it is why this result belongs in this series rather than only in an election roundup. The 2024 BRICS post on this blog argued that the bloc's significance was less about its institutional machinery than about the specific people willing to champion it. Lula is the clearest case - he has been the most consistent advocate for expanding BRICS and for non-dollar settlement among its members, across three decades and now four terms.
A Flavio Bolsonaro presidency would have aligned Brazil toward Washington and left BRICS without its most committed large-economy advocate at precisely the moment the Gulf crisis is testing how much of the multipolar thesis is real. Instead the bloc keeps its champion for another term. That is a more consequential outcome for the new world order series than anything in the Gulf this month, and it arrived through a domestic runoff rather than through any of the mechanisms the series was watching.
The other reversal: a market opened, then closed
Here is the part I find genuinely remarkable as a piece of policy history.
Brazil legalised fixed-odds betting in 2018 and spent years building a licensing regime, opening what became one of the largest regulated betting markets in the world. Operators paid substantial licence fees to enter it.
On 25 September 2026, Brazil banned fixed-odds betting outright - sports betting and online casino games, offshore and domestic operators alike. Licensed operators were required to close their Brazilian businesses by 25 October, with no refund of licence fees.
The escalation through 2026 is visible in sequence:
| When | Measure |
|---|---|
| July 2026 | Betting adverts required to carry tobacco-style health warnings |
| 2026 | Bill 2.470/2026 bans bonuses, promotional credits, free bets, cashback, free spins, loyalty programmes, and betting on credit cards |
| 25 Sept 2026 | Fixed-odds betting banned outright |
| 25 Oct 2026 | Deadline for licensed operators to close, no fee refunds |
| 23 Nov 2026 | The measure lapses unless Congress converts it into law |
That last row matters and is easy to miss. The ban is a provisional measure, not settled law. It expires unless Congress converts it by 23 November, or sixty days later if extended. So as I write this, the largest betting market in Latin America is closed by an instrument that might yet lapse, which is an unusual state for an industry to be in.
The stated rationale was mental health, consumer protection and "the family economy" - which is the honest framing. The thing that moved Brazilian policy was not a moral objection to gambling. It was household balance sheets: evidence that low-income Brazilians were losing meaningful shares of income, including transfer payments, to betting apps.
The payments detail that matters
The measure bars banks and payment schemes from processing betting transactions, and Pix is named.
Pix is Brazil's instant payment system, state-built, nearly universal, and one of the genuine successes of public payments infrastructure anywhere in the world. Part II of the new world order series treated systems like Pix as evidence of the financial rewrite - national rails that reduce dependence on Western intermediaries.
What this ban demonstrates is the other edge of that argument, and it is one the series did not make. Rails you build yourself are rails you can switch off. A state that owns the payment layer can exclude an entire industry from the economy by instruction rather than by enforcement - no need to chase offshore operators or block domestic ones individually, because the money simply cannot move. That capability is a sovereignty gain and a control capability in the same object, and which one it looks like depends entirely on what it is pointed at. I framed national payment rails as an unambiguous good. They are an unambiguous capability, which is a different thing.
Romania takes the gradual route
The same policy turn is happening elsewhere with different instruments, and Romania is the clearest comparison because it has reached a similar destination without prohibition.
Since August 2025, Law 141/2025 has charged online operators an authorisation fee of 30% of gross gaming revenue, with a minimum of €480,000 - a level that functions as a barrier to entry as much as a tax. Government Emergency Ordinance 7/2026 then required local authorisation for physical venues, handing municipalities a much larger say in where land-based gambling may operate at all. A bill to raise the gambling age from 18 to 21 and tighten online advertising has passed the Senate and awaits final approval. And the regulator spent July consulting on rules for bonuses, terms and conditions, demo play, virtual credit and test accounts - the same promotional mechanics Brazil banned outright.
Underneath it, the structural shift that explains the urgency: Romania's market is moving to roughly 71% online against 29% land-based by the second half of 2026. Regulation designed for premises does not bind a market that has moved onto phones, which is the problem every jurisdiction in this position is actually solving.
What connects them
Two states, different instruments, same direction. Brazil used prohibition. Romania is using fees, siting control, age limits and promotional rules. Both are reversing a liberalisation they themselves enacted.
Three things are worth drawing out.
The fiscal case was weaker than it looked. Legal gambling is sold to finance ministries as revenue: licence fees, GGR taxes, formalisation of an existing grey market. What both cases suggest is that the receipts are smaller than the downstream costs once household debt, mental health and welfare-transfer leakage are counted. Brazil walking away from collected licence fees, with no refunds, is a government deciding the revenue was not worth it - which is a strong signal from a state with real fiscal pressure.
Promotional mechanics are the regulatory battleground, not the betting. Look at what both actually target: bonuses, free bets, cashback, loyalty schemes, credit-card funding, virtual credit. Those are the features that convert occasional betting into habitual betting. Regulators have worked out that the product is the retention mechanism rather than the wager, which is a more sophisticated read than the usual moralising.
And this is a cost-of-living policy. It belongs in the same category as the 89% of American voters who named cost of living as decisive. Betting losses are a household-balance-sheet problem, and governments under price pressure are discovering that an industry extracting discretionary income from low-income households is politically indefensible regardless of what it contributes to the treasury. Expect more of this, in more places, for that reason rather than a moral one.
What I would watch
Whether Brazil's Congress converts the ban by 23 November. If it lapses, the whole thing becomes a nine-week shutdown with permanent reputational damage to Brazil as a licensing jurisdiction, and no settled law - the worst of both. That is the near-term question.
Whether offshore volume simply absorbs the demand. Prohibition tests whether the payment-rail block actually works. If Brazilians keep betting through crypto or foreign intermediaries, the ban will have moved the activity beyond both taxation and consumer protection, which is the standard failure mode.
Whether Romania's gradual model outperforms. Two comparable experiments running simultaneously with different instruments is close to a natural experiment, and in three years there should be an answer about which approach actually reduced harm rather than relocating it.
And what Lula does with the fourth term on the BRICS file. A re-elected champion is not the same as a bloc with momentum, and the Gulf stress test suggested the financial side of the multipolar thesis is further behind than its security side.
Sources and further reading:
- NPR - in stunning victory, Brazil's Lula wins fourth presidential term
- CNBC - Brazil election 2026: Lula wins historic fourth term
- Al Jazeera - world reacts to Lula's victory
- Focus Gaming News - Brazil betting ban timeline, from 2018 legalisation to 2026
- iGaming Business - Brazil Senate committee approves restrictions on ads and betting sponsorship
- Payments High Risk - Brazil betting companies face new restrictions and tax pressure in 2026
- IMGL - gambling regulation reviewed in Romania
- SiGMA - Romania to consider new rules for online gambling
- Gaming and Media - Romania: regulation, taxation, and the shift towards online betting